Lately, there is a lot of hand-wringing in the media about the West’s, especially Western Europe’s, dependence on energy imports of Russia. Much has been made of Putin’s self-assured demeanor at the recent EU energy summit in Finland, and many commentators are troubled by Russia’s behaviour towards Shell in connection with the Sakhalin project, where the Russian government is trying to gets its pet oil company, Gazprom, in on the deal using its envirnmental regulator as the battering ram.
Clearly, Russia is not the nicest place in the world. It is no Western democracy. But it is also not the old Soviet Union either. There is a free press, people are free to travel, and while Putin’s government runs elections and the political system in general in ways that gives it the political advantage, nobody wins elections with 99.9% of the vote these days. Russia today is also not the down-and-out place it was 10 years ago, and perhaps it is this that is really bothering some people in the West. The relationship between the West and Russia is much more complex today than it was in 1996. Russia has put its economic house in order in many ways and is enjoying the enhanced power its vast energy reserves give it. Nothing wrong with that–every great power behaves this way.
The unfortunate fact about fossil fuels is that nature, or coincidence, or God (take your pick) put most of the world’s reserves in decidedly nasty places. The only Western democracies with significant oil and gas are the US (which consumes far more than it produces), Canada and the countries around the North Sea (but the North Sea fields will be pumped dry relatively soon). It is not as if we can say, “OK, we’ll just rely on Norwegian oil because the Norwegians are nice and civilised and democratic.” They are indeed all of those things, but they just do not have enough of the stuff to go around.
So the choice for Europe is to import from Russia, a country with a somewhat dodgy political system but at least a fellow European country, or from the Arab states. I know what I prefer. When we fuel our cars with Arab oil, we are supporting terrorism, Islamic fundamentalism, the enemies of Israel and of the West, and some of the most dictatorial regimes in the world. Compared to the Saudi Arabias or Irans of this world, Russia looks like a Jeffersonian democracy. So I know whom I would rather depend on!